The Mortal Instruments (The Graphic Novel)-Should You Read It?

Image result for mortal instruments graphic novelGenre: Manga/Young Adult Fiction/Paranormal

Rating: 5/5

First of all, I call this a manga rather than a graphic novel because 1) graphic novels are usually in color or printed on a shiny paper and 2) this was published by Yen Press, a well-known manga publisher in North America. I have reviews for: Lady Midnight, Lord of Shadows, and a special spotlight review on Tales from the Shadowhunter Academy as well, all of which likewise feature some of Cassandra Jean’s artwork.

Maybe I am biased (I try not to be), but this is one of my few 5/5 star ratings. It is an amazing adaptation of the first part (about half) of Cassandra Clare’s novel, City of Bones. Also, the art was done by Cassandra Jean, one of my personal favorite artists. All the work she does for the Shadowhunter novels is absolutely spot-on when it comes to what I, as a reader, think the characters look like. I even have the Shadowhunter Illustrated History with her artwork, the Mortal Instruments Coloring Book, and the tarot cards, all with Cassandra Jean’s work. If it hadn’t been for her beauty with Shadowhunter’s, I never would have found some of her other original work, such as Reindeer Boy (which is officially one of my favorites, also a manga published by Yen Press).

With all this fin stuff in mind, perhaps I should talk a bit about the story and to what extent it follows the novel. It has been about ten years since I first read City of Bones, and I am still a major Shadowhunter fan. This adaptation was not only done with beautiful art, but adapting the story was done well also. This first volume Introduces the reader to Clary Fray, a girl who enjoys a normal life with her friend, Simon. All that turns around when she witnesses a murder in the Pandemonium club.

Little did she know that it was a demon being murdered, and that Shadowhunters are meant to protect the mundane (human) world. When Jace Wayland discovers that Clary has the sight, he aims to bring her into the world of Shadowhunters, even though she does not want that…at first.

The three mortal instruments, the cup, the sword, and the mirror, are first described in this volume, and some of the history and lore of the Shadowhunters is introduced. The reader is also given some backstory by Jace, and the volume ends after Magnus’s party, when he warns Clary that her mother was hiding her from the terror of the Shadowhunter world.

I absolutely loved this adaptation; the art adds a different perspective when reading, in that I notice physical character interactions in a way that I did not notice when reading the novel originally. This is only volume one, and with the title being The Mortal Instruments, I will be assuming (and hoping) that it will cover the six books in the original story arc.

Related image

On another note, on the same day as this manga, the 10th anniversary edition of City of Bones was released, and it is one of the most beautiful books I have ever purchased. There is a number of colored interior art by Cassandra Jean both within the pages as well as the interior covers. There are also a number of black and white pieces of art added into various places, which will really add to the reading experience and has me greatly looking forward to reading the novel again and starting my Shadowhunter journey from where it all began over ten years ago. There are also added files from the Clave, which is an interesting part of this edition as well, and the binding is like that of an old book, giving it a chic feel of value.

Image result for city of bones 10th anniversary interior art


Highlight: Tales From the Shadowhunter Academy

latest (1272×1920)

Tales From the Shadowhunter Academy consists of ten short stories or novellas written by Cassandra Clare and various co-authors. These stories are connected by Simon Lewis, who was once human, became a vampire, and is now a mundane again having lost his memories in the events of City of Heavenly Fire. Through these novellas we get to see the road Simon takes to become a Shadowhunter and to gain his memories back, meeting some of our other favorite characters as guest speakers in the academy along the way. Each short story is introduced with a quote from the story as well as a wonderful comic book illustration by Cassandra Jean that give a bit of insight to the story before reading.

DISCLAIMER: I would HIGHLY recommend reading all the other major novels in the series (with the exclusion of The Bane Chronicles) before reading these short stories. There is a lot of intervention and new tales form some of the major characters across the Shadowhunter series spectrum.

Each novella will have its own summary and reflective review along with the introductory comic images.


“Welcome to Shadowhunter Academy” by Cassandra Clare and Sarah Rees Brennan

latest (1400×2100)

Simon leaves his family and friends behind with no memories of them from past events, only from the present. In this story, we are introduced to the Shadowhunter Academy and all its glory. Simon seems to be revered as a hero, but he has no recollection of what his part was in the previous war. More comfortable rooming in the dungeons with the other mundanes, Simon finds that being a Shadowhunter might be more challenging than he thought. With his new roommate and friend, George Lovelace (a boy adopted into a Shadowhunter family, making him a mundane as well), Simon is ready to take on whatever challenges the academy puts forth for him, whether it’s the lack of indoor plumbing, or the appearance of a surprising gust speaker in one of his first classes!

This is a good introduction to some of the characters we will see throughout the novellas, as well as the Shadowhunter Academy itself and how things work between the various students and staff present.


“The Lost Herondale” by Cassandra Clare and Robin Wasserman

tales-from-the-shadowhunter-academy-9781481443258.in02.jpg (1400×2100)

This story begins with some rigorous morning training, something that is a part of the academy daily life whether you are a mundane or of Shadowhunter blood. When Simon seemingly fails compared to everyone else (yet again), the coach keeps him back, along with 19 of the other supposedly top students in the class. A Downworlder has been causing problems, and Simon, among others, has been chose for this out-in-the-field training session to take care of the Downworlder. We learn that many of Simon’s classmates (including his roommate, George) thought he was lying about losing his memories just to seem laid back or cool. Before the students go out on their first “field” mission to kill a vampire, one of the institute heads comes in to talk about Tobias Herondale and how he left his own in battle, the worst thing a Shadowhunter could ever do. Since they could not find him to sentence him, they sentenced his pregnant wife to death. After finding out that Simon came face-to-face with the vampire on the mission and preferred to talk to it over killing it (although Isabelle comes in and destroys it), she confides in Simon that those many eyars ago (1818?) she saved the child from Tobias’s wife, placing an enchantment on her to make her appear that she was still pregnant. Simon learns that, out there somewhere, there is a lost line of Herondale’s living a mundane life. He debates on whether or not to tell Clary and Jace, but since he doesn’t know them that well at present, he decides to wait.

This story was interesting because I am a Tessa and Will fan, and learning even more history about the Herondale line was fun. I believe Tobias is Will’s grandfather’s brother (or something of the sort). Introducing this Herondale story gives us insight into potential Herondale’s that may join us in the future of the Shadowhunter novels, which is an interesting addition.


“The Whitechapel Fiend” by Cassandra Clare and Maureen Johnson

tales-from-the-shadowhunter-academy-9781481443258.in03.jpg (1400×2100)

Jace makes an appearance to help train the young Shadowhunters how to leap from heights and land in an efficient manner (through practice with a tree). Of course, Simon isn’t that thrilled or that great at the process. The students also get another guest speaker: Tessa. She recollects a story from 1888 when her children were very small and a demon was murdering women and removing their internal organs. Jessamine, Shadowhunter ghost and protector of the London Institute, figures the demon wants a mother. In an attempt to save the children and play mother, the Shadowhunters are able to dispel the demon whose murders brought upon the name of Jack the Ripper. Jace finally confronts Tessa, and the feeling of knowing there is another Herondale who shares his blood brings Jace Solace. Simon finally builds up the courage to write a letter to Isabelle, despite his lack of memories.

This story was interesting in that it went from the time skip of 2008 to 1888, bringing us back to a story told from Tessa’s time. The Infernal Devices being my favorite of Clare’s novels, the short story within the story was refreshing and fun to see some of the action with Tessa and Will as Shadowhunters as well as new parents.


“Nothing but Shadows” by Cassandra Clare and Sarah Rees Brennan

latest (629×949)

While Simon and Jon butt heads in class about the superiority of those with Shadowhunter blood over those without, he is asked to stay after class to hear a tale told by history teacher and warlock, Catarina Loss. A time jumps lands us back in 1899 with a thirteen-year-old James Herondale newly admitted to the Shadowhunter Academy. James is a shy bookworm with yellow eyes and begins his reputation at the academy poorly; all he really wants to do is make friends, but he may not have the social skills to do so. When an amiss battering ram being used on the practice field by the students should have killed James, he turned into a shadow, the hunk of wood going right through him. While he can bear marks, he has also inherited the strange demon powers his mother possesses. This makes his reputation even worse, and when a demon pyxis exercise goes terribly wrong, he is expelled. He isn’t alone, though; one other Shadowhunter aims to be expelled with him and become his parabatai. With the outcome of the story, Simon reflects upon his friendship with Clary and decides to write to her and maybe someday ask her to be his parabatai.

This story was the most interesting so far. We get to see a bit of James Herondale, what kind of Shadowhunter and person he is, and how he met his parabatai. I have a feeling that this will be a lead-in to Clare’s newest series, The Last Hours coming in 2018 and featuring the children of some of our favorite Shadowhunters. By far the best of the novellas in the book (thus far).


“The Evil We Love” by Cassandra Clare and Robin Wasserman

latest (658×992)

It’s nearly summer time at the Academy and the students get a leave-off from the Inquisitor himself, Robert Lightwood, with assistance, to Simon’s dismay, from his daughter, Isabelle. Robert wants to leave the students off to ponder about when given power and how to use (or not use) those powers given. He tells of a time when he was a member of Valentine’s Circle, how close he was to the start of the Dark War himself. We meet Stephen Herondale, a new addition to the Circle, but the most devoted to Valentine. We also get to see the parabatai relationships between Lucian Graymark and Valentine as well as Robert Lightwood and Michael Wayland. The story jumps back and forth between Robert and his rush with power in 1984, and 2008 where Simon fights with his own dilemmas over Isabelle. When Isabelle asks the other Academy students to help her summon a demon at the end-of-year party, they all oblige, except for two: Simon and another girl. It turns out that the demon summoning was a test of following those with power blindly, the Inquisitor hoping some of his lectures of his time with Valentine would strike the students, but no. Only two students could resist the call of power, could demonstrate the difference between right and wrong based on Robert’s lectures. Now Simon continues his quest to find himself and possibly set up a date with Isabelle.

This story was okay, but not the most interesting. The better aspects of this story were the past that we get to see with some of the parents of our favorite Shadowhunters from The Mortal Instruments. We get a glimpse of Valentine’s ideal power and goals, and why he aims at such goals through the weakness of the Clave, his hatred of Downworlders, and the death of his father. We also see a little bit more about Robert Lightwood and why he, perhaps, treats Alec the way he does and was maybe never completely in love with his wife from the start.


“Pale Kings and Princes” by Cassandra Clare and Robin Wasserman

tales-from-the-shadowhunter-academy-9781481443258.in04.jpg (1400×2100)

Summer break has ended and Simon is back at the academy, aiming to write a 500 word paper about what he did over the summer, like possibly ruin his relationship with Isabelle yet again. When Helen Blackthorn comes to tell the story about how her father was ensnared by the magic of faeries, she is ridiculed for her half-blood nature. Many Shadowhunters died and lost family members to the faeries that joined Sebastian in the war, and faeries are looked down upon no matter the situation. When Simon goes to chat with Helen after class, to explain that he find the discrimination wrong since she is a Shadowhunter, he finds Isabelle hiding in wait for him in Helen’s living area. Simon and Isabelle are urged to go on a date, and Isabelle keeps trying to get Simon to do things Jace has suggested, when Simon is nothing like Jace! In the end, Simon is invited to Helen’s wedding during her brief stay in Idris, but he is invited as Isabelle’s plus one!

This story is a bit of a lead-in to the next story, which shows Helen’s wedding and a glimpse of the other Blackthorn children as well as Mark in his Wild Hunt setting. A major difference between this story and others is that Helen’s story is short and told within a few pages of her summarizing events, whereas other stories go back in time and tell the event from that perspective. This made the story have a little less impact, but this story was more about Simon and Isabelle rebuilding their relationship, rather than the learning focus of an academy lecturer.


“Bitter of Tongue” by Cassandra Clare and Sarah Rees Brennan

latest (1400×2100)

Everyone at the Academy gets a turn to lead a mission, and not it is George’s turn. He is extremely excited, but tends to lack the caution of Simon and some of the elite Shadowhunters. When George’s team is sent to investigate a faerie sighting, George wants the group to split off just far enough that the three pairs can hear each other. When George spots the faerie that has been drawing mundanes in, Simon lunges at him to stop, noticing that it is a trap. With his lunge, Simon falls into the world of the faeries. The one who lured him in with the trap wants to claim him, but Mark Blackthorn lays claim on Simon as Simon is to be a Shadowhunter and thus one of Mark’s brethren. Simon lays the news that there is no search party for Mark, but his sister is getting married. As Mark relays his memories of his sibling, Simon struggles to put a name with a face, knowing Clary had mentioned the Blackthorns at least a few times. When Isabelle comes to help Simon escape from the faerieland, they return to George and the group to a warm welcome. The story ends with Simon and Isabelle’s attendance of Helen’s wedding, where Simon humbly observes the Blackthorn children and reflects upon Mark’s previous ruminations.

This is actually a unique sort of lead-in story for Lady Midnight. The time period of this story places Mark with the Wild Hunt and we find that Emma and Julian have not been through the parabatai ceremony just yet. It also gives us the view of Mark’s feelings of being in the land of faerie and his feelings toward his family members that we do not see much of in Lady Midnight as his end of the tale.


“The Fiery Trial” by Cassandra Clare and Maureen Johnson

tales-from-the-shadowhunter-academy-9781481443258.in06.jpg (1400×2100)

Simon and Clary have been invited by Emma Carstairs and Julian Blackthorn to skip out on school and duties to witness their parabatai ceremony. When Magnus gets a portal ready for travel, Simon and Clary find themselves in a familiar, yet obscure and empty, Central Park. When Clary vanishes in thin air and the angel statue’s gaze follows Simon, he knows something is wrong. A swan boat takes Simon through the tunnel of love where Jace tells Simon it is important to remember when they first met, it is key information for events to come. Simon is also visited by various females that he has had in is life, including Maia, Maureen, and Clary. When Simon must choose to save one, he knows who it is immediately and Jumps into the river, fighting the current to save his best friend. When he sees that she is struggling to reach him as well, they awake to find themselves back on a couch at the Academy having tea. It turns out that Jem, Magnus, and Catarina gave them the hallucinogen water of Lake Lyn, the trial by water that has shown the two that they are, in fact, meant to be parabatai. When they finally attend the Fiery Trial in the City of Bones, Simon sees a glimpse of something behind the eyes of Emma and Julian, something he recognizes in himself. It is in that moment that Simon’s memory decides to come forth, showing him a time when he was going to confess his love to Clary, and a time when he indirectly met Jace as well.

At first this story was very strange. Reading it did have the effect of one drinking a hallucinogenic water from a sacred lake. When it was obviously something that was not really happening, it was more interesting to read into the things that the visiting characters of Simon’s subconscious were hinting at. When Simon realizes that being parabatai means being inseparable, he and Clary know that their relationship is perfect for the bond, they just need to let Jace know. It was fun seeing Julian and Emma during their ceremony knowing their feelings for each other and seeing how reluctant they seemed to be because of those feelings, yet they continued on with the Fiery Trial. It will be fun to see Simon and Clary paired at long last as well.


“Born to Endless Night” by Cassandra Clare and Sarah Rees Brennan

latest (658×992)

Magnus has been invited to be a guest teacher at the Academy for a few months. Bringing Alec with him, he has only eyes for his lover, while everyone else seems to have eyes for him. When Simon and his friends opt for some archery practice, they are stopped in their tracks when they find a blue warlock baby left on the steps of the Academy. When the whole Lightwood family makes an appearance on campus to see the baby, Magnus realizes that he and Alec may be in this for the long haul. When Simon finally approached Alec about the alleged reason for the dislike between the two, Alec clarifies that Simon not only saved his life, but the lives of those he loves. Simon tells Alec that Jace implied something quite different, and the two parabatai duke it out in their own way. With little baby Max Lightwood joining the family. Maryse has the excitement of being a grandmother, and Magnus rationalized that Alec will one day leave them, but he and Max will live forever.

This was a nice introductory to the adopted baby warlock that we only get a small glimpse of in Lady Midnight. It was interesting to see how Alec and Magnus came to take him in in the first place and the feelings behind adopting the child as well. It is also a potential lead-in for future novels. I hope we get to see more of baby Max Lightwood!


“Angels Twice Ascending” by Cassandra Clare and Robin Wasserman

latest (658×992)

It is finally time for the class of mundanes to attempt ascension. Some of the mundanes have double thoughts about becoming Shadowhunters. While they showed prowess in the events of the Academy, not all were fit to become Shadowhunters, and those who were cowards fled the night before. When ascension time comes, Simon is nervous, but he has Clary and Isabelle there, knowing they have faith in his becoming a Shadowhunter. While we know from events that Simon successfully ascends and later becomes Clary’s parabatai, not all the students make it through ascension, and the brutal death of those unworthy is terrifying. To Simon, even those who did not make it were still worthy, and they had a place among Shadowhunters in a home belonging to the past.

Trying to be a bit more vague with the last story, it was a good one. I was a bit upset, but the resolution and burial of a dear friend as a Shadowhunter brings us back to the London Institute and an allusion to Jessamine, while not explicitly stated in the story. It was a great end to a wonderful collection of stories that really add to many aspects of the Shadowhunter series.